Colorado Sheepherders: Human Rights Violations on the Border?
by
KREX News Room
by
John Dzenitis
Story Created:
Feb 7, 2011 at 9:16 PM MDT
Story Updated:
Feb 7, 2011 at 11:48 PM MDT
Two men search for signs of life, traveling in a pickup truck on snow-packed roads criss-crossing the vast, frozen landscape straddling the Utah-Colorado border.
“It’s a lot of guesswork,” Mesa State Spanish professor Tom Acker says, sitting in the passenger seat. “It’s easier in the wintertime. They keep their campers closer to the roads plowed by the oil and gas companies.”
In the driver seat is Ignacio Alvarado, a man who knows this seemingly monotonous and nondescript land well. He was once a Colorado sheepherder who led his flock through this very area.
“Ignacio’s sense of direction is amazing,” Acker says. “You could drop him anywhere here and he would know exactly where he is.”
Acker and Alvarado are volunteers for Colorado Legal Services’ Sheepherder Project. It’s a watchdog group for migrant workers--usually from Peru, Chile, and Mexico--hired by Colorado ranchers as temporary laborers under the H-2A program. They’re searching for “campitos," or rolling camper trailers lived in by sheepherders. They’re currently over the Utah line near the mining camp of Bonanza.
After an hour’s search, they find a campito.
“We’re gonna drive by,” Acker says, cautiously looking at the distant campito through binoculars. “Hopefully, the worker is alone and we can talk to him.”
Alvarado pulls the pickup truck next to the campito. Looking through binoculars, Alvarado says a sheepherder is coming back in.
What once was only a speck on the horizon becomes a Peruvian sheepherder mounted on a painted horse, trotting towards Acker and Alvarado. The pair introduces themselves to the sheepherder, Alejandro. After giving Alejandro warm blankets and winter clothes, the sheepherder invites them into his campito for a chat.
“Sometimes they’re scared to talk to us,” Acker says. “A lot of them aren’t allowed to have visitors. Some are worried their H-2A visas won’t be renewed. Some ranchers specifically tell their workers not to talk to us.”
If the sheepherder is cooperative, Acker asks a them a series of questions, ranging from the condition of their campito to the last time they were allowed vacation.
Alejandro talks about a chronic eye problem from lack of proper sunglasses. He complained of the problem for a year and a half, but instead of being taken to a doctor, he was given a bottle of over-the-counter eye drops. Now, Alejandro says his eye is blind.
“I wish we could get him medical attention, but that’s just impossible to do this far out right now,” Acker said.
Some of the sheepherders live in relative luxury, with solar panels and even television. But a good number are living without running water and electricity, their trailers in various states of disrepair.
A week later, on a nighttime trip searching public lands near the ghost town of Cisco, Utah, Acker found an example of an inadequate and illegal campito. With a rickety wooden door and turn-of-the-century design, the campito provided little respite from the extreme cold.
“Normally, you would see some state seal indicating this camper was approved for use,” Acker said, shining a flashlight above the doorway. “Clearly, this one is not fitting that bill.”
During the same nighttime trip, Acker and Alvarado find another sheepherder. Of Chilean descent, the man once worked as a sheepherder in California.
“How often are you able to go visit friends, go to the church, go to a party, go to the village, go to a store?” Acker asks the man.
The answer: “Never.”
“He’s ended up not having any water because they didn’t bring him water,” Acker says. He ended up having to drink from the same pond as his sheep.
The interview had to be paused when an employee of the rancher drove up, unannounced, in a pickup truck. The sheepherder exchanged a few words outside, and the rancher drove off. He steps back into the campito, shaking his head.
“He’s worried he may get in trouble now for having visitors,” Acker said. “He hopes the rancher just thinks we were some family members.”
Acker says there are a number of responsible ranchers that do treat their sheepherders well.
“The few that I’ve spoken to that are honest, they’ll admit there are some really bad actors,” Acker said.
But others are committing serious violations.
“Why do you all circle the wagons whenever there’s a criticism of your industry?” Acker asks. “Why don’t you identify the ones that are misbehaving and treating their workers badly, and make examples of them, so that your entire industry isn’t tarred?”
You have indicated this comment should be removed.
The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .
jerry g said on Saturday, Jul 28 at 2:15 PM
"sheepherders" in previous post, not "sheepherds".
jerry garcia said on Saturday, Jul 28 at 2:14 PM
tom maneotis is a criminal, plain and simple, who thinks he's entitled to do what he wants, where he wants, and to whom he wants. it's like the wild west with no laws in his world and if left unregulated, there would dead sheepherds found in his "campitos" parked illegaly on other's land.
Kadi said on Monday, Feb 20 at 9:07 PM
I'm doing a paper on Modern Slavery in the United States. Anyone know where I can find more information on Colorado? It seems like it's really hard to actually find information
Antonyo said on Wednesday, Feb 9 at 10:40 AM
I don't doubt there's some good ranchers that try hard to provide for their sheepherders, but the bad ones are the ones that get so offended when truth is exposed. That's when, instead of admitting that there's a problem, work to fix it, they turn their attention to the ones exposing it, and start to attack them, loading the conversation with words like "sneaking", "manipulate" etc.We have to remember, when somebody is opressed and is not able to speak for himself, that does not mean, hi is happy with it.
Dave Jackson said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 9:05 PM
This type of exploitation is experienced by immigrants and migrant workers every day as they strive for opportunity in a country that welcomes their cheap labor but recoils at their presence and fails to protect their rights. -The Southern Poverty Law Center It is appalling that these conditions continue to exist in this country. In 1906 Upton Sinclair wrote in his book the "Jungle" about how he mingled with the foreign-born "wage slaves" in their tenements and heard how they'd been mistreated and ripped off. He saw for himself the sloppy practices in the packing houses and the mind-numbing, 12-hour-a-day schedule. It would seem that little has changed in 100 plus years.
Leslie Maneotis said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 8:36 PM
You so called do gooders have no idea how hard we work in all kinds of weather conditions so you people can go to the store and buy your food and I am not just talking about lamb, I am talking about any food, beef, your vegetables and etc. I 'd like to see you Tom Acker or any of you others follow in mine or my husbands shoes or any other sheep rancher for that matter for one week and see how long you last. You think we like working in 20 below weather trying to keep baby lambs alive? This is our living and we are proud of it no matter how hard we work, so leave us and our herders alone and mind your own business, these guys want to be here...
Leslie Maneotis said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 8:23 PM
If these guys didn't want to come to this country then why are they here? They are not forced to come to this country and herd sheep, they so choose to come here. We've had guys come on several contracts, so why do they come back if things are so deplorable for them here? Do they have running water in Peru? Ask many of them about putting their kids thru school and college because of us the sheep rancher. What is it any of Tom Acker business or anyone elses if these guys want to come over here and make a better life for their families? They all have cell phones and plenty of food and supplies that they need. Do you people think we as the sheep rancher set on our butts and do nothing why these guys do all the work, well let me tell you something we are right out there with these guys in all kinds of weather conditions working just as hard as they do.
Ernie said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 8:17 PM
Marv Roberts, I don't know who told you what, but the fact is that if a shepherd was working with me, he would not have slept in the truck, he would have stayed in the cabin. I have more respect for someone than you describe. Please tell the truth. Mr. Acker, a study showed that shepherds earn and save more than you are accounting. During the 2010 Legislative session, the Senate Ag committee reviewed you and your groups information as well as the sheep industry info. Because your information was misrepresented the bill died by a unanimous vote. I don't believe that throwing rocks at this industry and making us seem so indecent, unrespectful human beings is the way to approach. I take it to heart when I'm accused of mistreatment. Shepherds are vital to our operations and believe it or not I want to do what I can for them in appreciation. My father was a shepherd and my brother and I herded sheep for our Dad. We will continue to pay what the markets allow us to do, as well federal law.
Johnny said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 7:51 PM
The sheepherders are working where people from around the world come to backpack in and enjoy the mountains. Someone needs to tell these hikers about the loneliness they may encounter!! Are the herders mistreated because they are out there by themselves? The herder wants to go to "village" to party, with who? If they are from Peru, who would they know in the village, Tom Acker?? They are hired to herd sheep and they know that when they come here.
Marv Roberts said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 2:55 PM
A couple years ago I meet somebody who was a sheepherder over 16 years ago. He told me “I was pretty young and I did not know that my work condition was a real human and labor right issue. I spent over 10-14 hour every day in the range for $450 in the month. I remember in the winter time when my boss came looking for me later in the night. Always I was in the pickup of the truck because the warm cabin was for my boss and his 2 dogs. His name is Ernie Echart”. I think, in this problem its necessary to attend 2 aspects: the labor condition for the range workers and the mental behaviors of several directives of this industry in Colorado. They were working for decades without labor control and you can see how they lose the balance to looking for good solutions for all in this issue.
Marv Roberts said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 2:54 PM
One local community group in the western is collecting winter clothing in the last 3 months, after they knew about 3 sheepherders in the region who were dressing with summer old clothing in the past October-November. Their employer offered to them some appropriate clothing, but always is the same history. Also, I was trying to reach other Shepherder, a family in this case, with 2 children living in those 8 feet trailer. We were very concern about their access to education and medical attention, but it was impossible to reach them because the employer moved them into the open range in some area of the national forest.
Aaron said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 1:04 PM
I grew up on sheep ranch,and I find the article to be very one sided. While I agree that there are deplorable working conditions for some herders, the notion of no running water and electricity is laughable. The herders are out in open country. The idea that they did not bring a herder water when there is obviously several feet of snow on the ground is also laughable; you melt snow the same way a mountaineer would. Also, many herders are not "allowed" visitors due to the real threat of rustlers who take advantage of herders and then abscond with several lambs. Days off? Please. If you take even one day off be prepared to have many of your animals fall victim to coyotes or human predators. Should there be better medical care? Yes. Plenty of food? Yes. Better pay? Definitely. The first two are the rancher's job, but the last one is dictated by a marketplace that prefers New Zealand and Aussie wool, meat, etc. I can assure you the ranchers barely make a living. They, too, are very poor
Tom Acker said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 11:48 AM
I want to correct my mistake in earlier comment: it's not $2 a day rather $2 an hour they are currently being paid.
Tom Acker said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 11:41 AM
Because the imbalance of power is so drastic ( the rancher can opt to send you back to country of origin without any justification) few herders would risk that. We don’t sneak for fear of ranchers, after all, they are using public lands which are open to us all. We know that in most cases, a worker would never feel free to express himself with the rancher present. We recently interviewed workers who had no visas or passports because the rancher who hired them confiscated them. These same workers also had not been paid since arriving many months ago to live two to a “campito” ( I use the diminutive form because the workers themselves do). Ernie insists that paying workers less than minimum wage is justifiable—is under $2 a day a fair wage? This industry has problems, people are making money exploiting workers’ ignorance and desperation. The H2A wage scales for range workers needs to be changed to reflect 2011 not as they now reflect 1960! Tom Acker
Fred said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 11:14 AM
Yo Ernie, I know some ranchers who hire from south of the boarder. Most are fair, but a few dollars separate it from slavery. Making some money is better than no money. Call the State Dept....funny yet sad. I bet you would complain if your pizza was late.
Ernie Etchart said on Tuesday, Feb 8 at 1:16 AM
Tommy Acker and Ignacio Avacado are frightened to speak with herders in the presence of ranchers. This leaves one to question why they fear the rancher? Maybe with the rancher can address those concerns they have and could make sense of it all. When these two go sneaking around day or night trying to manipulate herders with gifts and loaded questions leaves me with a bad feeling about fairness to the rancher. Acker claims that many herders refuse to talk to him for fear of the rancher, so he claims. Maybe the herder is satisfied and accepts the way he is being treated. Sheep herders care for the ranchers sheep and the rancher wants the best care for his sheep possible. If a herder is not being cared for to his satisfaction the herder will quit. No one is that desperate that he will forgo food and water to maintain that job. The herder also can call the State Labor Dept., his embassy or other authorities to report. They have cell phones. Herders live in a sheepcamp, campo, not campito.
Add a comment
Most Popular