tater said on Tuesday, Feb 14 at 7:30 PM

An Islamic song? Good God don't be stupid and place the teacher on administrative leave. What a fool she is!

Anonymous said on Tuesday, Feb 14 at 8:11 PM

If it was a Christian song, they would not be standing behind the teacher and the song. This song is being allowed on the basis that it promotes "diversity" which is politically correct to do. I don't have a problem with the song being sung, however I do have a problem with the glaring double standard where different beliefs are treated differently.

Roger says said on Tuesday, Feb 14 at 8:57 PM

Good Old Diversity strikes again - Let's go full steam ahead - Please let me know when I can hear a children's choir in our public schools sing "Jesus Loves Me, This I Know?"

J J said on Tuesday, Feb 14 at 9:42 PM

Wonder what the FAITH of this music teacher is? Diversity is NOT strength. It is weakness. That is what the NWO wants...division. This music teacher needs to be disciplined...

Fellow Educator said on Tuesday, Feb 14 at 11:14 PM

It's good to see so many people interested in the lives of our young people. Let's keep their interests, their learning and their future in mind as we continue the discussion.

jh said on Tuesday, Feb 14 at 11:18 PM

This boy should be commended for standing up for what's right. This teacher should be suspended. WAKE UP AMERICA!

SueLyn said on Tuesday, Feb 14 at 11:57 PM

How ODD. People scream about the (non-existent) separation of church and state, but when someone mentions the impropriety of sing a religious hymn of a religion that demands all non-believers be either killed or enslaved, the real nut-cases crawl out of the woodwork. If all you 'anonymous' type are so enamored with moslem hymns, start you own choir and charge admission.

CrustyOldGeezer said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 12:16 AM

Just as an aside 'anonymous'.... Unless you are a devote moslem, in their country you would either be dead or a slave. Why is it ok for them to practice slavery, while you condemn this nation for the mistakes of our past that ended 150 years ago? And why do you not have a problem with the moslem practice murdering anybody of any other Faith? YOU have some serious emotional issues that need to be seen to by a professional. Perhaps a nice Jewish Psychiatrist could help you. Maybe a survivor of Auschwitz?

Brandon Mills said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 1:41 AM

Neither I, or the student that said this have anything against Islam. The reason he was uncomfortable about it was because the translated words state, "There is no god but Allah." There is pretty much a double standard because nobody is allowed to mention anything about the Christian God at school, yet it is okay for them to teach a song that not only praises another religion's god, but goes against what many students believe by saying the Christian God or the god or gods of whatever religion they believe don't exist.

Lisa Coulson said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 4:17 AM

Singing both religious and secular music from different cultures is one of the best ways students can learn about different cultures, you don't have to be Muslim to sing and appreciate an Islamic song just like you don't need to be Buddhist to enjoy Chinese food. It is a cultural experience, something many of those who have responded here seem to have lacked in their own education based on some of the ignorant comments. This is nothing new, public school choral programs have used a wide range of religious and secular music for decades and any of those responding about how Christian songs wouldn't be defended have clearly NEVER sang in a school choir because probably about half of the songs school choirs sing are Christian religious songs from traditional Latin choral pieces to Gospel spirituals. I find it very troubling that a student is taking issue specifically with an Islamic song, as I'm sure the choir's repertoire includes a wide range of music from several different cultures.

Lisa Coulson said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 7:40 AM

To anonymous: Your comment would make sense if hymns and Christian religious songs were banned from public school choirs. This is most certainly NOT the case, public school choirs include a great deal of religious music which is exactly why it is necessary to include music from other faiths and cultures in public school choral curriculum since the vast majority of material available to Western choral programs is Christian religious music. Without the inclusion of religious music school choirs would be extremely limited in their choices, so school choirs are able to include religious material in ways other public school classrooms and subject can't. For every 1 Muslim or Jewish song a public school choir sings they probably have 5 or 6 Christian religious songs in their repertoire. Maybe actually take a look at the repertoire of a public school choir before assuming that hymns are not allowed.

Grum. said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 8:59 AM

dearest fellow educator/anonymous, It is obvious that you knowledge of history is a bit lacking in reality. MOSLEMS worked with a few african tribes to attack neighboring villages, killing every person that did not meet the minimum standards of the SLAVE TRADE. The arab moslems got the slaves and the conquering tribe got the lands and the rest of the spoils. Most of the slaves went to Europe, with a fair percentage coming to the Americas, both North and South as well as the Caribbean Islands. When the Western world did away with slavery, the moslem arab slave trade did not just simply die away. And yes, the slave industry is alive and well to this day. To believe otherwise is dangerously stupid.

guest said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 10:16 AM

i have nothing against some religous songs but i dont think its necessary for any school choir. especially a muslum hymn . bunch of b s i dont blame the kid

Jan said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 10:32 AM

I want to commend James for speaking his conviction and not strapping on a bomb to do so. The Bible says, "Let the words of my mouth and the meditation of my heart be acceptable to You, O Lord". With that in mind, then yes, it does matter what comes out of the mouth of a believer in Jesus. James has just exercised his right to freedom of speech and notice he did not force anyone to stand with him.

boomer49 said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 11:21 AM

good to see a strong xenophobic cell of theocratic whack jobs on the western slope...and folks say a very small gene pool is a problem in this day and age, how silly.

J2 said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 12:24 PM

Is Mr Kitrland living by his convictions? I thought he was a christian. I thought he believed this country was founded on christian beliefs.

Nun said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 12:50 PM

One cannot deny the symbolism of the video and its correlation with the three horsemen of the apocalypse. Even without translation the music is moving. Fortunantly for James Harper he lives in the US and can decide what songs he sings. Unfortunantly he seems filled with anger and fear of something he does not understand. Good for the teacher attempting to enlighten students to culture outside their protected realm.

Straytok said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 1:47 PM

Who cares? If the young man is not comfortable singing the song, he has a right to those thoughts and feelings. Good for him for saying something! My son is also in GJHS Choir and he's ok with it. Same God, different religions... what a concept.

Sageratt said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 2:20 PM

Stop the double standard. Don't be a hypocrate this idea of christian or nothing is wrong. America was founded on freedom of religon. Either ban ALL religous related music from schools or allow All different kinds of religous music (Native American,taoism, budhism, jewish, islamic, muslim, hindu,rastafari, ect.)What's wrong with cultural diversity? If you want a christian only music atmosphere, then put your child in private school. I respect and support everyones right to worship as they choose, even if it differs from my beliefs, but I do not condone one group forcing their beliefs on another. Include them all or ban them all.

Bill said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 2:31 PM

Good for that young man. Truly, orthodox or conservative Muslims, when following their holy book will lead to violence such as 9/11. Orthodox or conservative Christians, when following the New Testament will lead to peace.

B.Dillback said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 2:42 PM

I served a year in Afghanistan and a year in Iraq. I know, first-hand, how women are treated there, how the United States is hated after we have poured billions of dollars into their stinking countries and how they would kill us all of they could - so why do people coddle their religion in the US? The same religion that tells them to kill all of us that are not muslims. This nation has become so politically-correct, that when they do have total rule, you'll regret it - and Shariah law is well on its way in our country. Make no mistake about it. They would be having a fit for a Christian song to be song singing "Jesus is the Only Way". I admire this young man for standing up for what he believes!

T said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 2:48 PM

Here let mehelp you raghead lovers out. but one verse translates to "There is no truth except Allah" and "Allah is the only eternal and immortal." Still in love with Marcia Bilbo and the propaganda minister?

John Q said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 2:55 PM

Well you know, the separation of church and state only applies to Christian faiths and holidays... all part of the progressive 'new normal' for America. Remember that at the polls.

B.Dillback said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 3:00 PM

All gods are not equal - There is only One True God and satan believes in One God and trembles at His Name. No other name under heaven where men can be saved but the name of Jesus....so...no - all paths do NOT leave to God, that is just what satan wants you to believe. Doesn't matter how many temper tantrums and names you want to call me - God's Word (The Holy Bible) is true and all men who say opposite are liars. All of this can be found in the Holy Bible - not the Koran or Quran however you think it needs to be spelled.

SUE said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 3:10 PM

SCHOOLS HAVE INDOCTRINATED OUR CHILDREN BY LEFTIST UNION MEMBERS WHO ARE LEAVING MUNICIPALITIES BANKRUPT AND YOU BROKE. ON TOP OF IT YOU ARE BEING MANDATED TO PAY FOR ABORTION, BIRTH CONTROL , AND BAILING-OUT THE RICH DONORS. THIS IS NOT A PARANOID THINKING- ITS' REALLY HERE IN YOUR LIVES. WAKE UP PEOPLE TO THE PROPAGANDA. DEMAND THE SCHOLL DISTRICT CHEIF BE FIRED. HOMESCHOOL YOUR CHILDREN AND REMEMBER THIS ON ELECTION DAY- AND PRAY .

Pete Davis said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 3:30 PM

Sing, 'ONWARD CHRISTIAN SOLDIERS' It's about time we Christians wake and smell the intrusion in our faith, by being Christian Soldiers and fight the evil that has entered into our lives. Surely , if we do not fight we will be a conquered people. Lack of doing nothing means defeat !!

Edmund Burke said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 3:33 PM

According to Mr. Kirtland, singing praise to Allah is OK since it promotes “diversity”. I guess that diversity does not include Christians or Jews. Any song that praised Christianity or Judaism would cause outrage from Liberals, Progressives and the ACLU. The Koran and Sharia law do not promote “diversity” of beliefs: Koran 5:51 O ye who believe! take not the Jews and the Christians for your friends and protectors: They are but friends and protectors to each other. And he amongst you that turns to them (for friendship) is of them. Verily God guideth not a people unjust. Koran 48:29: "Those who follow Muhammad are merciless to the unbelievers but kind to each other." Koran 66:9 O Prophet! make war on the infidels and hypocrites, and deal rigorously with them. Hell shall be their abode! and wretched the passage to it!

Megen said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 3:38 PM

Christianity is a religion all others are called diversity. See how easy that is. Not a word from the ACLU, atheist or the left. Double standards. Equality? I see nothing wrong with Islam or song but when you treat one religion as diversity and the other as religion?

Edmund Burke said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 3:45 PM

Fellow Educator. You are having trouble naming a Muslim nation that practices slavery? The Sudan and Mauritania comes to mind. Both are Muslim states and practice widespread slavery. Many other Muslim states practiced slavery well into the 20th century.

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 4:05 PM

Shame on Marcia Wieland, Jeff Kirtland and any other teacher/administrator responsible for this insane stunt! If YOU are so fond of Islam go hang out in the M.E. for awhile. Make sure you let them know you're American. They'd love to show you just how diverse and tolerant they are, especially to Marcia.

Carol said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 4:19 PM

Good for the kid! Stand up for OUR COUNTRY! Muslims are not happy in the countries they come FROM, so they come here and stir up trouble to try to make us like them!

BobbyMcjay said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 4:25 PM

That 'upbeat' music is the same they played as they cut Nick Berg's head off. You can maybe find the video by Googling "Nick Berg". I also notice that in the video, they show the spread of Islam with scenes of fire, and at the end there is a flag with a sword on it. That's how the Moors spread into Europe. When the Pope said Islam "is a religion of the sword" Islamists forced him to back pedal under threat of violence.

Daniel said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 4:31 PM

Attention all you bigots and racist... Christians and Muslims....PRAY TO THE SAME GOD

Jack Davis said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 4:45 PM

Kudos to James Harper. Jeff Kirtland and Marcia Wieland should be fired.

Victor Connor said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 4:57 PM

The Maracia and the school officials that backed him/her up should all be fired. Try mentioning Jesus or even "God" in any school event and its out. So now Allah is OK, but Jesus is not.

Lynn said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 5:33 PM

Sorry Daniel, but to say Muslims and Christians pray to the same God is to show a lack of understanding of either. The Koran says Allah has no son...that anyone saying he is Allah's son is a liar. They say Jesus is just a prophet. The Bible states Jesus is the Son of God, that He was sent by God, That He is God. There is no common ground on this. James stood up for his beliefs. That is to be commended. Doing so does not make one a bigot or racist.

Robert James Burkholder said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 5:53 PM

Is this story real? I hadn't heard of it until today on Free Republic. If true I salute this senior.Too often our public schools promote crabs in a brine bucket and little Patriotism.No American public school ought endorse or promote Islam as this song does, The "progressive" educators are one big reason for our failing schools.

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 6:02 PM

what a non story, waste of time. Krex = braindead

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 6:15 PM

This is nothing more than taught intolerance. Religious music is a staple for Choir music. All through High School and College I sang 100's of songs that were Christian based songs. Why is it okay to sing Christian music but not Islamic. It is nothing more than hypocrisy and ignorance. If people want Islamic songs to be banned then Christian, and every other religious based music must be banned. There shouldn't be a double standard. Either schools fully accept various forms of Religious music, or all forms of religious music should be banned. I hope this young man learns some acceptance, and tolerance.

Lech Dharma said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 6:29 PM

The BIGGER picture here, is "WHY" in the world---out of all the possible pieces of music ever written for voice---was "that" particular song chosen by the choir director? Student participation in the after-school choir may be "voluntary", but use of a public institution---like the school---and a public employees means taxpayer money is being used to advance an idelogical viewpoint: multiculturalism, and political correctness. The ad ridiculum political promotion of those 2 concepts are detroying the social cohesion of our American society. Despite our President's reluctance to "name" America's enemy in our ongoing War on Terrorism, it is "radical Islam." Would this song have been well-received if performed at Ground Zero on the anniversary of 9-11?

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 6:56 PM

As an alumni of the Vocal Music department of both GJHS and CMU, I have spent my entire musical career so far singing Christian music with religious text. I would have LOVED to have a little bit of diversity in my musical training but studying under a devoutly conservative professor made it impossible for me to get any kind of experience other than Christian music in my schooling. In a world where minorities are so beaten down in public school and in society alike, it seems to me that the ONLY solution to the problem is to teach acceptance and love all people and cultures. Individual people and the music that comes from different cultures are not the perpetrators of terrorism in our nation. Accepting these people is the first step toward a peaceful world. Also, when a school program is voluntary, it seems to me the more appropriate response on the part of this student would be to opt out of singing the song rather than to belittle and restrain everyone else's experiences in choir.

Blithe said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 7:24 PM

I'm one of those who thinks if you're going to get all worked up about Christianity in schools, you have to disallow all the other religions too. Pick another song, quit trying to prostelyze Islam to the kids.

Doc said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 7:55 PM

too much talk and not enough action.......talk is cheap and congrats to Jim and those that back him. Now how do "we the People" get organized and insure that none of our American students, let alone those of us that have to pay taxes, are subject to this? RISE UP people

me said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 8:27 PM

Daniel, you're an idiot if you truly believe that allah and god are the same...show me where god says kill innocent people..

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 8:35 PM

To the commenter below named "Me." It was called the crusades, enough said.

Doughboy said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 8:52 PM

"there is no other truth except Allah" Does no one realize that "Allahu akbar" and "La'illah illa'ullah" mean 'Allah is great' and 'there is no god but Allah'. These are muezzins' cries and the original phrase of the Qur'an, itself the first part of the shahada, the statement of conversion to Islam. These are affirmations of belief and the statements used by Islamic terrorists. And you want to call Allah the same as the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob? By what fruits do you know and see the sameness, when it is those who follow Allah that are willing to kill themselves and as many others as possible to demonstrate their belief? The school should turn itself into a madrassa and make Quranic recitation its curriculum, as is done all over the Islamic world. Just to be thorough. (End ridicule) "I am the Way, the Truth and the Life." Blessed be the name of the Lord, Jesus Christ.

Ann said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 9:00 PM

I thought the liberal government wants total separation of church and state. No religion brought into a public school. We can no longer sing Christmas songs, Christmas trees (oh excuse me, but we can have a Holiday Tree). I commend James for standing up for his principles. He shows how much smarter he is than his choir teacher. I hope his grades won't suffer because of his beliefs.

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 9:22 PM

KREX said that he was forced to quit choir? Mens choir is a volunteered group. What good did James Harper do? He created controversy and unnecessary headaches. Way to go to Marcia Wieland. Thank you for being an awesome teacher to all.

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 9:28 PM

I would like to inform every last one of you that, along with Zikr, the men's choir will be singing a Christian piece entitled "Prayer of the Children". They have sung MANY Christian pieces in the past, and not an eye has been batted because of it. Sacred music is 75% of what choirs all around the world sing. This is no different.

Cultures aren't equal=truth said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 9:52 PM

Cultures aren't equal. It is one thing to put a man on the moon and quite another to put a bone in your nose.

Jenni said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 9:57 PM

Thank you for standing up for Christians!

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 10:13 PM

Krex is a joke. Not to be confused with journalism.

J. Foxworthy said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 10:28 PM

If you consider television dangerous, but routinely carry explosives in your clothing... You may be a Muslim -

Clara said on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 11:42 PM

I would like to set a few things straight for those who assume this is an assault on Christianity. Get your facts right before attacking the district, the teacher, and schools in general. Ms. Weiland’s Holiday Extravaganza concerts are full of Christian music. Christmas decorations can be found in the commons, library, and classrooms. Every morning, students stand to recite the Pledge, including “One nation under God.” Young Life openly promotes and recruits on campus. A Christian program promoting abstinence advertises through posters in the hallways.Fellowship of Christian Athletes meets at lunch. Students wear t-shirts with Bible quotes. Parts of the Bible are required reading for some classes. The district supports all of these activities. I am a Christian, but I understand that I live in a country with religious freedom. That means diversity. What makes terrorists dangerous? A lack of tolerance and a belief that everyone should believe the same thing in the same way.

JR said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 12:08 AM

I wouldn't care about singing 'an Islamic song' in choir. I only take exception to singing the verse 'there is no God but Allah'. Isn't that how you convert to Islam, declaring those same words? That would be problematic, even symbolically. As to religious songs, don't care. Music is music.

TomW from Texas said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 3:52 AM

Are there any muslim students in this choir? If, in fact, they do sing Christian & Jewish songs from time-to-time, my guess is that there are no Muslim students, otherwise they would, beyond a doubt, be objecting.

joseph said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 4:43 AM

It makes no difference what the director's intent was ,the song violates the seperation of church and state/public institutions. This country is great for going after christians but it can turn a blind eye to a Muslim inserting his beliefs in a song. The director should be repremanded but the school principal should be fired along with everyone who voted not to stop this. This is a country where everyone is supposed to be treated equally but obviously not in this state. And Colorado wonders why it has so much trouble with it's youth. You spout one set of standards but practice another and these students see it and reject what they are supposed to learn in school. And here i thought California led the way in talking out of both sides of the mouth . Colorado is catching up fast.

Cathy said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 7:46 AM

We can say what we like, but believe me every devout Muslim knows that the first of the five pillars that all good Muslims state are those same words that are the cause of objection in the song. Muslims in Arab countries like the Sudan have been beheaded for converting to Christianity (there's tolerance for you), but if they will just state, "There is no God but Allah", they will be let go. Yet, due to our lack of knowledge, our children do not know what they are carelessly tossing aside.

T said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 8:59 AM

Every student should walk out, an this school system should be put front an center of attention to the American people

Dave2E said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 9:12 AM

James Harper is a young man to be proud of. He didn't just blindly follow the crowd or the teacher. He followed his heart and mind ...wow look at the translation of what he was being asked say ...what a concept!! It's too bad that James is much to sharp to be a Congressman.... Way to go James ....hang in there 3 or 4 more months then RUN LIKE HELL or ZIKR away from there. HARPER for Prez!!!!

Floyd said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 9:15 AM

The reason the islamics hate Jews, is because muhammed was killed by his Jewish wife. Islam is a religion of hatred, even the islamic allah, is not claimed to be a holy god.

Harriet - Huntsville, Al said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 9:20 AM

How said for America, founded as a Christian nation. The school's principal, choir director and spokeman Jeff Kirtland are certainly not decent role models. In my opinion they are extremely cowardly and are trying to follow the "in crowd" that is trying to rule this country. There will be a huge price to pay in the end. Thank goodness for young men like James Harper. I know his family is extremely proud of him. I certainly am.

jim not stupid said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 9:31 AM

ALLAH ..THATS HOW YOU SAY GOD OR JEHOVAH OR YAHAVA IN ARIBIC. GOD IS MOST GREAT or arabic ALLAH AKBAR , الله أكبر or spanish DIOS ES MAS GRANDE or hebrew אלוהים גדול ביותר

jim not stupid said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 9:36 AM

should i tell my Arabic CHRISTIAN not to say GOD in Arabic

dbm said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 9:51 AM

allah not Jesus, nor God, but a demon spirit

calywud said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 9:53 AM

I agree that we should respect other religions BUT this is a CHRISTIAN nation. I bet the Islams do not expect their children to sing Christian songs and then tell them, oh, you aren't worshiping unless you practice.. You are worshiping when you sing! We should be singing Christian songs in our nation because we stand for the Christian principles that our country was founded on. Thank you James for standing up for what you believe. We need ADULTS in this country to do the same. There should be no question about whether or not we sing Christian songs - it should be an automatic. It is part of our country's foundation. James is an example of the freedoms we all enjoy! Shame on that teacher for even teaching our kids such a song!!! Doesn't she realize there are those kids that may believe and follow the teachings of that song. Kids are searching for answers. The answers they can only find in the one true and living God, Jesus Christ! Don't be feeding them Islamic hatred of Christians!

DAVID CAULEY said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 10:02 AM

We need another president like Thomas Jefferson who established many of the christian principles to be followed by government including the Bible being taught in public schools, encouraged clergymen to hold public office, funded religious books for public libraries, funded salaries for missionaries, established schools of theology. Thomas Jefferson was the ACLU's worst nightmare! These are the principles our country was founded on. Why are we so concerned about introducing Islamic beliefs? We are NOT an Islamic nation - we are a Christian Nation! We should be teaching our kids Christian songs that lead them to worship the true and living God!! Let the Islamic following the foundation of their government in their country, not ours! Christians are punished for practicing Christianity in their country!!! James is right on the money!! He is right and I encourage him and back him 100%. We need more James Harper's in this country!

June roach said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 10:10 AM

Good for this young man for standing up for what is right ! When will others that should take a stand wake up ????

Danny said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 10:21 AM

Students can’t even mention Christ during Christmas, so why is it now appropriate for a school to force students to sing an Islamic worship song. This has nothing to do with Diversity.

PUDLOWSKI said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 10:27 AM

THANKS JAMES FOR HAVING THE GUTS TO STAND UP AND NOT BE AN IDOLTERER. YOUR TEACHER IS A MORON. IF THEY WANT TO SING ABOUT THE FALSE GOD ALLAH THEN GO SING IN SYRIA AND LET ME KNOW HOW THAT WORKS OUT!!

Kali Politis said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 10:47 AM

I'm a liberal secularist. Singing Islamic supremacy songs has NO place in public schools. If my child is forced to sing that "Allah is the Lord," I will SUE the school board and be sure that all people involved are removed from their positions. SHAME ON THESE PEOPLE for pushing the Islamic supremacist agenda on our children.

Pam said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 10:48 AM

There is no question of a double standard here. The muslims would be up in arms and protesting if any Christian song were taught to their children. We are constantly being bombarded and attacked by our own political correctness. Kudos to this young man. Watch The Third Jihad to learn more about how we are harming ourselves by our own correctness and phobia of being labeled racist.

Kathy Wappel said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 10:55 AM

I also find it interesting that the 2 posts I've read in favor of singing the Muslim song are from 2 people who won't even post their names. Just "anonymous" Hmmm...

Gale said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 11:06 AM

Good for you Mr. Harper! WE are a Christian nationa and the majority rules and the majority are Christians. This flies in the face of our soldiers who are fighting in Islamic nations- and dying. STAND UP AND VOTE THIS NOV.! or you will be giving up your right to rights

Jeff In Rhode Island said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 11:30 AM

This is a rather slanted story, from everythin I have read, they sing all sorts of spiritual songs, people here Islam and freak out! All religions are nothing more than "sanctioned" cults. Congradulations Christian right wing, here is another bad guy to pick on. Btw, I am not anti-religion, google the Cranston West prayer banner which I support and you will see what I mean.

Larry Shepherd said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 11:45 AM

Good for you young man, don't let the liberals fool you, Islam is a religion not a nationality. If my children had been at that school I would file a lawsuit against the school district. The dual standards of the liberals in this country are despicable. As so many have already said, if the song contained the same phrase with Jesus instead of the Muslim God, the liberals woul dbe up in arms in protest. Know that many people are behind you 100%

Jeff said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 12:16 PM

"Me thinks he doth protest too much":-0

I hope I'm not alone. said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 12:26 PM

Am I the only one that learned this in school? Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances. Or does this basic freedom only apply to certain people?

Yvonne Mullican said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 12:29 PM

James Harper...YOU ROCK...Thank GOD for Young Adults as you... I am a 54 year old grandmother of 3 and you Sir are a True Blessing to America !!!!

OW in Oklahoma said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 12:45 PM

First, it is NOT a fact that most founding fathers were liberal deists. That's liberal propaganda. Read John Adams' biography. Muslims cry "Death" to anyone they object to, so obviously there were no Muslims in the choir. Separation of church and state is NOT in the constitution. It says very simply "Congress shall make no law". States can do what they want.

Randall Ambrose said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 12:49 PM

1 “I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. You shall have no other gods before Me. 2 “You shall not make for yourself a carved image, or any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth; you shall not bow down to them nor serve them. For I, the Lord your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children to the third and fourth generations of those who hate Me, but showing mercy to thousands, to those who love Me and keep My Commandments.

Webb said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 1:22 PM

Fire this teacher and stop the spreqad of Islam into our country! If this would have been a Christian song with praises to God, then the ACLU would have gotten involved, it would have been a messy situation for this school and teacher, and the song would be pulled immediately. But since it is Muslim, everyone will break their backs to make sure it is shoved down the throats of students, willing or not. This double standard is blasphemous and wrong. This is a Christian nation no matter what big O says about it, especially since he was never born in the US anyway.

Ronda said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 1:26 PM

I just think it is a double standard if it is about diversity & diversity in religion then how come the use of the word God is not allowed & also why don't sing a christian song. At my sons high school graduation the Senior girl who was the class valedictorian had to sneak a simple prayer into her speech. The whole auditorium applauded & appreciated her words & anyone who did not simply did not have to stand or clap. Christians are being squelched at every corner from showing their faith. So why should it be different for Islam?

Jhink said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 1:53 PM

Intolerance is pullling this country apart. Even the headline is meant to provoke. According to the article, the song isn't meant for worship and the only thing that "forced" this young man to quit is his own intolerance. What ever happened to freedom in this country? Freedom of or from religion is guaranteed in the constitution. Would people be upset if or would the student be upset if the choir was singing a song from a Catholic hymnal? Just stop it! Intolerance is what is killing America!

GJHS TEACHER said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 2:07 PM

How can poeple say that Christianity is opressed in US schools when every single morning we pledge alligence to one nation under GOD? We have a two week CHRISTmas break and a CHRISTmas choir concert full of CHRISTmas songs. A CHRISTAN church group meets in my classroom every Monday at lunch.

Jeff In Rhode Island said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 2:33 PM

I would like to hear from the rest of the quire who didn't quit and had no issue with singing a non-Christian song. I respect this young man for standing up for his beliefs and not wanting to participate, but he shouldn't expect everyone to bend to his will either. As for the ACLU bashing, it is justified, there is a double standard with them, but that doesn't mean the rest of us have to have equally shaky motives. I applaud thos of you who have the reading comprehension to see this for the non-story that it should be. (Sabrina, Jhink, Former GJ)

Anonymous said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 2:53 PM

I SEE ALLAH IN HALLELUIAH: HALLELUIAH!!!ALLAH IS IN THE BIBLE TOO!! Many Muslims Sing Songs about the Love of Jesus Christ; Even when they go to Church. I am a Christian Muslim Jew! How is that? Am I worshiping another G_D?

Paul (from Australia) said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 3:06 PM

CONGRATULATIONS and applaud for this gutsy young man James Harper who made a brave stand against the tide of Islam that is sweeping across America and many other nations of the world. To make a public stand for his faith when it means going against that which is 'popular and permissible' takes GUTS and this young man has demonstrated just that. Even a blind man could see that this song is about 'tolerance' and praise for the Muslim faith. An earlier writer (Jisbond) said " I am a Christiam Muslim Jew! How is that?" Well it's simply not possible - either you are a Christian or you're not - and James Harper has clearly demonstrated who and what he is. Have a look at the comments by 'the educators' and see where they are coming from - it's rather obvious. So sack the teacher - and parents - please stand up for your children and your country! Thank you James and may God (YHWH - the one true God) bless you, you stand out above the crowd.

Dissapointed GHHS student said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 3:17 PM

I find it dissapointing that our city is being torn into two over a persons opinion. Last night this controversial story made it onto Denver news and the seperation continues. I feel that as a country our religious freedom is being attacked. Everyones tollerance has taken a step back from all sides, we need to call down and agree that this is none of our business and it should have never gotten th...is big. As for the students approach on the whole issue it think its his way of getting attition and everyone is giving in to this attempt. Even me. Yes it is a fact that every single high school in America will sing religious songs, and yes it will not be only one specific religion. In my choir everyone is accepted for who they are and what religion they may be. This student is in my choir and should know this, but apparently decided to "forget" how tolerant we are in this department. This is my opinion on the matter. Goodbye

JISBOND said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 3:31 PM

MY MOTHER IS ISHMAELITE; MY FATHER IS OF ISAAC'S FAMILY; AND IWAS RAISED ANGLICAN!! HOW IS THAT?! HALLELUIAH IS YA-ALLAH!! IN ARABIC!!

PAGOP said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 4:14 PM

Ummm, as I understand it, the PC police have raised enough of a stick over the past few years that kids are not allowed to sing songs at Christmas that have a religious context or contain the word "Christ." They aren't even allowed to call them "Christmas shows" or "Christmas break." I guess this is OK because it relates to Islam, not Christianity, and the PC police find it OK.

annoyed said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 4:35 PM

Take a look at the GJHS choir website. There are recordings of several christian songs including one called "The Lord Has Risen Indeed." Get over your persecution complex and try a little tolerance.

Dan said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 4:58 PM

Its all love and fun and tolerant until you find that another religion wants to kill you and thousands in the twin towers. You rightous ones talk all day about diversity and tolerance, where are you cowards when we needed you in Iraq and Afganastan.

Shadows on the Wall said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 5:26 PM

Replace Allaah in the lyrics below from the song he refused to sing with Jesus and the teacher would have been demonized. "Allaah is the only One who is eternal and immortal and rest are perishable and will be destroyed by Allaah"

Verdad said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 6:39 PM

The Politically Liberal (PC) position on religious freedom allows Islamic religious practices and observances, even installing footbaths in public universities; but Christian religious practices and observances are prohibited "because they might offend someone". For Islam, "we need to be tolerant and celebrate diversity", but for Christianity "that violates separation of church and state" (which is not true; the 1st amendment only prohibits the government from forcing the public to give money to a state sanctioned church). The young man is simply exercising his freedom to refrain from practicing someone else's religious observances.

Carol J. Land said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 6:47 PM

Allah is how you say god for the moon god that was a false god and honored by Mohammed and his family....Mohammed went into a cave a few times and came out with the koran. Mohammed was a person created by our God, Jehovah Lord God......Mohammed was a person just like us in need of a savior........and he chose to follow a false god and taught all to kill everyone that would not worship that false god called Allah.....That is not our God's name - the creator of the heavens and the universe.....Jehovah God is His name and they are NOT in no way the same person.....When will all people read and understand this........And Jehovah Lord God is the ONLY real God, all else is sinking sand.......and very damaging.......Our God sent Jesus (His only son, perfect) to die for us so that we do not have to die and go to hell.....allah the moon god wants to make everyone die for him.....What a difference......

Wake up America said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 7:15 PM

These are exactly the words and beliefs that the Al Qaida cult adheres to, that we are fighting against, and that many of our brave men and women have died fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan. I will NEVER apologize for my faith nor worship the god of Islam! This young man is to be commended.

Paul (from Australia) because we face the same issues said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 7:27 PM

I agree with Carol J. Land's comments. However, just to make my position absolutely clear, in no way am I against the Muslim people, rather I am against the god of the Muslims(Islam - anti-Christ)as pointed out by Carol. These Muslim people need a Saviour too, and Jesus died for the sins of ALL, including the Muslims - if they will accept His sacrifice. Either you are a Christian or you're not! No-one can have a foot in two camps - and James has clearly made it known which camp his foot is in. Good on ya!

Shannon said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 9:15 PM

This reporter is a joke. This happens all the time- it is nothing new.

Ron said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 10:15 PM

Thank God at least one has the courage to stand up for what he believes. You can say it's not worship but I will never say utter the words in song, poem, speech or anything else that there is any other God than Jehovah. How many christian churches will you find in Iran, Iraq, Egypt or another other muslin country. We had better start standing up for what we believe or we will become a muslin nation as well....don't think so. That is their goal and they have the numbers and power to do it only if we LET them. They was their flag flying over the Whitehouse. Have we forgot 9/11...that was done to us in the name Allah. No there is only one God and only one God that sent his son to die for me and you and it's NOT Allah. You've got to stand for something or you'll fall for anything. You keep standing young man and hopefully many will follow. ,,

GJHS parent said on Thursday, Feb 16 at 11:39 PM

Want to know why those who support the choir director or the song aren't posting their names-fear of backlash. Too many comments here are from people who do not know the whole story. 1)Christian songs are NOT forbidden-the sole fundraiser for the choir department is a CHRISTmas program performed at a Christian church. They also perform Jewish songs, Native American songs and music from other cultures. 2)They do say the Pledge everyday, including "Under God". If a student does not want to participate, fine, they don't say it. 3)To me, this issue isn't about religion, it's about free speech. I have a problem with one child making this hard for the rest of the choir and the director. It's hard not to be bitter about this when my son comes home and tells me about the comments he's hearing at school about this whole scenario. God is alive and well at GJHS. This has gotten completely out of control.

Anonymous said on Friday, Feb 17 at 5:27 AM

A "religious song", christ almighty the teacher should be fired. Doesn't matter if it a Christian or Islamic song, neither belong in a public school. You want to sing religious songs then go to a privately funded religious school.

william wallace said on Friday, Feb 17 at 7:43 AM

GJHS parent /One can understand your concerns however sticking your head in the sand /NOT a solution to the situation. James having put a valid complaint as such he's entitled justice. In speaking out / to his credit / nothing will change if people afraid in speaking out when a wrong done. In having a son such as James such an parent should thank Almighty & stand proud.

william wallace said on Friday, Feb 17 at 7:54 AM

PC / Your comment within your right as in making / however t'was lacking in respect not only toward ISLAM but also to MUSLIMS.

Oh, The Irony said on Friday, Feb 17 at 9:00 AM

Unfortunately this gentlemen is a bit of a hypocrite. Mr. Harper, where was your outrage when Christian music was being sung at a public highschool earlier this year? This is all about hating Islam. If you are going to allow other spiritual songs which is fine by me, then Islamic songs are just as good as Christian/Jew/Native American. It is all or nothing pal. I hope Grand Junction stands up against this intolerance cloaked in “Christianity” The Christian right wing can chew on that while they vote for a mormon as President in November,. LOL

Next up... said on Friday, Feb 17 at 9:25 AM

"Onward Christian Soldiers!" Let's keep that "diversity" alive and well! Let the secularists' and anti-Chrstian's heads explode!

william wallace said on Friday, Feb 17 at 10:15 AM

GJHS parent / To reward / punish in the same breath is to sit on the fence /thus the easy way out. James IS entitled in having NOT 50% but that of 100% of support. // His case has gone to the people /whom found a 100% in his favour / thus he entitled to an 100% support.

Carolyn Daniels said on Friday, Feb 17 at 10:37 AM

and thankYOU for your post including poor Hamza in Saudi Arabia. It could happen here if Christians don't join the spiritual battle that is raging. I am an ex-public school teacher--had to bail out when they threw out the Lord Jesus and kept every false teaching,"religions", and false philosophy imaginable with which young minds are brainwashed. Those true Christians who've decided to keep a strong stand while in this 'prison' using our money through huge tax dollars, are truly on the front lines. Hang in there Christian soldier youth! however, there is a time to re-group I believe and I'm thinking public schools are a total loss now. I've been 'in it' and watching from a homechool distance for decades. I'm not sure it's worth the time anymore for the public grew up in those schools; but those who are not ignorant ("my people perish for lack of knowledge" Hosea said)--can still bring some light with Bible studies

Hamza Kashgiri would tell you said on Friday, Feb 17 at 11:10 AM

Not sure what you are saying William, but Hamza is questioning his faith and he has been sentenced to death for such a "crime" committed against the "religion of peace." This is indeed their FORM OF JUSTICE! And by any other name, it still smells rotten my friend! This choir woman is indoctrinating her students in that religion and unknown to them, as they are ignorant with ignorant parents, lulling them into participating in a religious act central and OBLIGATORY to the muslim religion. My second point was to the parents who claim to support their children without knowing WHAT they are sanctioning! Maybe you missed it, but I support James in his courage to stand up and refuse to be indoctrinated.

Carolyn Daniels said on Friday, Feb 17 at 11:34 AM

maybe he is saying that James should take the school district to court to explain why he is being made to practice the religion of Islam in a public school. (not a bad idea to 'appeal to them through their pocketbook')

Carof lyn Daniels said on Friday, Feb 17 at 11:46 AM

true William, they have forced James into having to make this stand and should be held accountable now; there will be also another Judge they will give account to and His Son (Jesus) is the believer's advocate/Lawyer. I think any institution that clouds, perverts, or smears in any way the truth God left us in His Word, the Bible, that factlater will be sorry they did.

Carolyn Daniels said on Friday, Feb 17 at 12:38 PM

so true, and as He said: "He that rejected Me, and receiveth not My Words, hath One that judgeth him: the word that I have spoken, the same shall judge himm in the last day." John 12:48

Mike said on Friday, Feb 17 at 1:02 PM

There is no God.

Hamza Kashgiri said on Friday, Feb 17 at 1:18 PM

@mike. There is no mike without God. Thank you for having enough respect to capitalize the g in God. "Oh my God, I am so sorry for being blinded to Your Word. Please forgive me, in the name of my Lord and Savior, Your Son, Jesus Christ." You just prayed to God mike. Hope it helps your lost soul.

Carolyn Daniels said on Friday, Feb 17 at 1:41 PM

ah, but dear Mike--He is! and I've known Him personally for nearly 50 years-He's proved Himself to me and been a loving, faithful, just God and that's why I know His Name: Jesus in Acts 17:21-30 He had Paul write: God that made the world and all things therein...giveth life and breath and all things (and let us know) we "should seek the Lord...though he be not far from everyone of us: for in Him we live, and move and have our being (and another place says "by Him all things consist-are held together)...and now commands all men everywhere to repent...for he will judge the world by that Man whom He hath ordained (Jesus) ..." and Mike it will be soon--so please seek Him for He will then reveal Himself to you--the BEST Person I ever met-sweetest Treasure I have and will have for all eternity--I want you to be there...and not in that horrible hell place for it is real. Jesus had lots to say about its reality in the new testatment--please read in there.

Jason B. said on Friday, Feb 17 at 2:39 PM

Folks, I read a different discussion about this story, and in it some folks insisted that Jews, Christians and Muslims all worship the same "God". I could not stay silent about that, so here are some facts pertaining to those comments: “Allah” has no son, (Sura 23.91 and 25.2) and therefore cannot possibly be the father of Jesus Christ. In fact, Islam teaches that placing anyone (or anything) on a level of parity (or partnership) with “Allah” is in fact blasphemous and worth of capital punishment. “Allah” and the one true God of the Bible are not one and the same. Allah also refers to himself as “deceptive” and “the best of all deceivers” (Sura 3.54). This is also directly contradictory to the holy, sinless nature of the Lord of Hosts, the one true God of the Christian faith (who is elaborated upon in detail in the Bible, the Holy Word of God). “Allah” and the one true God of the Bible are not one and the same. I have several more points here, but not enough space to elaborate.

william wallace said on Friday, Feb 17 at 3:00 PM

Carof lyn Daniels / I suggest a site you should visit which will greatly increase your spiritual understanding (if so wish in having faith in the power of Almighty. The site being (words of peace) in which there be an selection of videos in which Prem Rawat explains meditation /in one's turning the senses inwards / doing so to bring a unfolding of the "Spiritual Self" in one having such "spiritual experience" which bring one clarity in understanding thus in answering all questions one asks. I do not wish go into understanding which your not ready for (however) I'll explain as put forth to you some understanding as broaden knowledge towards /The Son of God. Throuhgout history of human life there be Spiritual Teachers /amongst such be an "Teachers of Teachers" present time the teacher of teachers is Prem Rawat via meditation he will guide whom ask turn the senses inwards thus one able look on the light of creation to know the word of God as the breath of ife.

Anonymous said on Friday, Feb 17 at 3:07 PM

That is what is great about this country!!!! If the boy didn't feel comfortable singing this song then he has the right to quit the choir. If people don't want to hear the choir sing this song don't go to the performance. I feel the same way about people who don't like the Christians. I respect your right to believe any thing you want. Please respect my right to worship as I choose and if you don't like that don't bother to be around me!!!!!!! If you don't like the nativity scene turn your head!!! Simple... You all came here for religious freedom, n ow practice it.....

Anonymous said on Friday, Feb 17 at 3:28 PM

Anonymous / Your looking at life commenting from state of development which most people have not reached / your to be praised // as congratrulated /such heights your in having reached taken much effort as *many lives in achieving //thus again / my congratulations HOWEVER i must bring to your attention that you grant a bit more understanding to your brothers as sisters whom having not matched your deserved achievments ( thus show a bit more mercy & understanding in your attitude judgement to us (inferior) struggling souls.

Carolyn Daniels said on Friday, Feb 17 at 5:27 PM

dear William Wallace/ you're so 'helpful' or I know you probably intended to be; HOWEVER I have EVERYthing I need already: God/Jesus Who lives in me-His Holy Spirit resides within those who are His-who've been born again. He promised to teach and guide us-His sheep.I've found Him faithful and with me in over 50 years; He speaks to me through His Word, the Holy Bible and therefore I am protected from 'false teachers' therefore--and there are many--many claim falsely His Name even; So we need to read it but unless we have His Spirit living in us, we won't be able to understand it and have His mind. I hope you'll meet Him someday for Jesus fully let folks know He IS GOD. You need Him and I pray you come to know Him soon.

william walllace said on Friday, Feb 17 at 5:55 PM

Carolyn Daniels / Best go at a pace you feel comfortable. However the information which I gave if followed through t'woud open heavens gates to you if such be your wish. Allow the Almighty to be your guiding light /your love.

Anonymous said on Friday, Feb 17 at 7:48 PM

As an American, Christian and great grandmother, I am so proud of this young man who had the guts to stand up to the 'lily-livered' people running this school. Wonder what most of our Vets think about this? Songs of praise to other Gods in our Nation's school is an abomination! To actually know songs or prais

Anonymous said on Friday, Feb 17 at 7:58 PM

Message to Obama's people: Get these Islam, Muslim and any other 'lam 'Ism's out of this country..and YOU with them! "Amnesty for Illegals you say"? This young man puts the rest of us to shame! "In God We Trust"

Shayna Thomas said on Friday, Feb 17 at 10:23 PM

WOMEN IN ISLAM For discussion of this subject please join us in the forum by clicking here. Tabari I:280 Because Allah afflicted Eve, all of the women of the world menstruate and are stupid. "A wom

Commentor said on Saturday, Feb 18 at 3:44 AM

Truly that song not suitable for public schools, I heard it. How they selected this one for the students? That school is totaly wrong in this case. As a school for the public they cannot simply select religious songs and allow students to sing it, it looks easy for them to say if they dont like they dont have to, Then what is the purpose of being a public school. At the same time they also cannot ask an islam student to sing church prayers because its against islam.

american said on Saturday, Feb 18 at 6:33 AM

diversity, gotta love it, i hear at the concert they will be having a towel drive and a 150k IED run. Proceeds benefit the Obama campaign fund!!

Jan said on Saturday, Feb 18 at 10:46 AM

I would say that James Harper has done more to "educate" us in the area of cultural diversity by questioning and bringing this situation to light. I have researched the issues from all sides so as to form an educated opinion regarding the subject/issue. I suspect that would not have happened if I was handed the music and told a short summation about the song. Maybe the district should offer James a teaching position...

Andy said on Saturday, Feb 18 at 10:51 AM

Our plans to bring Sharia law to America are now nearly complete. Praise Allah. Next up: mandatory gay abortions for everyone!

Again? said on Monday, Feb 20 at 9:45 AM

I'm against all religious teachings/songs/tom foolery in schools. But the christian hypocrisy is hilarious. They are always up in arms when someone is trampling on their "religious freedoms" when someone wants to remove the 10 commandments from a public school or object to a christian song being sung by a school choir. But when it's another religion that wants to be afforded the same supposed rights, all I see is outrage. Way to keep it classy and hypocrisy free christians.

OPEN MINDED said on Thursday, Feb 23 at 7:30 AM

For crying out loud! There are so many stories going around who knows what the truth is. The only problem here is that singing a song of any religion in school is wrong! RELIGION AND SCHOOL should be SEPERATE! Just like religion and Goverment should be seperate! And No one religion is the right religion. There are many, and should all be respected. Telling one person how to live is wrong.

robert donaldson said on Thursday, Feb 23 at 11:11 PM

wooow good turn out of commentary jesus said I AM the way the truth and the life so that leaves the other figures of various worship in the mire. When it comes to truth the devil knows not. so if it is not Jesus in you who is it there abiding within your frame? Praise the God of abraham isaac and jacob they can be looking forward as all followers of the truth can to the coming resurection to eternal life, where we will not hear any singing that worships gods that are both deaf and dead.

Amanda said on Wednesday, Mar 14 at 7:46 PM

God, you all are idiots. The choir sings Christian songs ALL THE TIME along with other religious pieces. If religion were to be excluded from the choir program entirely, you'd be kicking the Hallelujah Chorus, most Mozart and Bach, and pretty much anything with Latin in it. "Domine Deus, Jesu Christe" ring any bells? The thing is, public school choirs (at least this one) DON'T actually discriminate against Christian music. The ACLU and the 'ignorant' and 'intolerant' liberals have never attacked the teachers/administration over Christianity in the choir program. This is a specific prejudice that you are acting on against the Islamic religion. At least call it what it is! There's a reason for that prejudice and many Americans have it, but these students made an educated decision to include the piece and James had the option of sitting out - other boys with a similar complaint played percussion. Hell, hum along if you don't like the words!

Jake said on Sunday, Mar 25 at 7:38 PM

An Islamic song? That's horrible. I mean, if it were a Christian song, it'd be a completely different story, wouldn't it? I mean, it isn't like Christians bombed our twin towers. I mean, even though radical Christians crusaded through eastern Europe, massacring entire nations, Christianity is clearly the better religion. After all, Christianity was the religion of almost Klu Klux Klan members, and look at how much good they did for our nation! Foolish teacher to think Islamic music was okay to play in class. It's not like religious songs are taught in school because of their educational merit, and that the presence of religious overtones is not considered in the selection process. Songs are not taught in class because they teach unique styles and techniques to students, they are taught because we love Jesus, and every other American should too! Force Christianity upon them!

neisha harris said on Wednesday, May 9 at 9:39 AM

what this is not okay i think

Mart said on Saturday, Aug 4 at 6:09 PM

Ann, since you can't even manage to spell "countrys" correctly within the proper context, perhaps you should refrain from making stupid comments. In case you've forgotten, (or never knew),one of the guiding principals America was founded on is freedom of religion. And no, that doesn't just cover which Christian denomination you belong to, but ALL religion. But Ann, to make you feel better, let's just throw out the Constitution and declare Christianity the only Religion allowed in America! But wait a minute....what happens when the Catholics decide to ban the Baptists? Or the Lutherans decide to bomb the Methodists? 99% of Muslims are peaceful, fairly tolerant people. The fundamentalist Islamic terrorists are no different than the fundamentalist "Christian" terrorists, who decide to kill and maim innocent people by bombing abortion clinics. But shhhh....we don't want to talk about THAT, do we? Honestly, some of you are walking billboards for "You can't fix stupid"!